Comment and Discuss on TeluguPeople.com Articles

naaku pennundi raasesta. norundi vagesta annattundi. okka maata ku maro maataku pontane ledu. merit anedi evadi sottu kadu. desabhivruddiki kavalasindi, merit unnavaallu kani, venakabadina taragutalam ani board pettukunna vaallu kadu. educaitonal institutations lo seats, government services lo udyogalu, villa taata sottu ayinattu, adedo janmahakku annattu prelaphanalu. reservations biksha kadu, anta kanna nichamaina, heyamainavi. biksha gadaina intintiki tirugutadu. aa maatram kashtam anna padataadu. villu adi kuda ledu. pass marks techchukune yogyata leni vaallaku kuda, IIT, IIMs lo seats reserve chesipettaalanta. siggu siggu. chaduvu kovadaniki kavalasina sadupaayalanni kalpiste, aa sadupaayalanu upayoginchukoni, merit aadharangaa avakaasaalu andipuchchukovaali. BC hostels, SC/ST hostels, schools lo fees maaf, extra pocket money, books konadaaniki money... innichchina chaduvukokunda, hostels lo, colleges lo godavalu pettukovadaniki tappa, inkemi pani cheyyani vaallaku iit, iims lo setas kaavala.. reservations ni eppudu biksha to compare cheyyakandi. ilaanti vallatona mammalni polustunnaru ani, bikshagaallu kulli potaaru.

Posted by: Madan TG At: 4, May 2006 9:52:50 PM IST

In the entire article, the only valid point is that merit doesnt belong to one particualr caste. I think it's very shameful in this day and age that somebody deliberately wants to be descriminated as backward just for getting additional advantages in educational and professional institutions. Are BCs the only community that has been descriminated several hundred years ago? Consider afro-americans that were ill treated centuries ago. they live with such pride and self respect and honor their country men without demanding so called reservations. India shud definitely have reservations but based on economic conditions rather than caste that comes with birth. now that is true equality. its totally shameful to want to have more in everything only b'coz a person is born in one particular caste. The sooner we get out of this 'backward caste so want more' attitude the better r our countries chances to grow.

Posted by: Mrs. Puja Srik At: 4, May 2006 9:48:51 PM IST

Dear Krishnaih Garu , As we know,OBCs historically suffered from one problem. They were not allowed access to the holy scriptures that the Brahmin was. So no cowherd or artisan could become a pundit. However, economically, a hundred years ago, they were no better or worse off than Brahmins. What has constituted 'education' and 'learning' over the last century or so, is not and has never been monopoly of the Brahmins. Education and learning has been provided in schools and colleges. The Brahmins had as much access to it as any other castes. Their financial resources were as meagre as most OBCs. The OBCs, over the years, have had similar access to a livelihood as an average brahmin. They are miles and miles better than the Dalits who led a sub-human existence. The only disadvantage one can envision non-brahmins as having would be discrimination-based. i.e if for any job, the selection in subjective, then brahmins would be given preference. Now if it is a privately owned company, then these rights to discriminate are inviolable. A person can be shamed or incentivized into having a non-discriminatory hiring policy, but should not be coerced by the state. When it comes to hiring for government jobs however, the government has a right to take steps to do whatever the public madate thinks fit. So if subjective discrimination is feared in government jobs, then to avoid it, reservations for OBCs, or for anyone actually... can be rationalised. But reservations, at least for OBCs, should be in place only to prevent discrimination. i.e if an otherwise capable candidate is being rejected only by virture of his caste. A quota in government jobs prevents such a discrimination....by and large. But on these grounds, considering that OBCs were no better or worse in terms of resources and access to education, than Brahmins, I fail to see the rationale behind reservations in completely-objective selection procedures such as JEE and CAT or any other admission entrances. In JEE or CAT, a candidate is just a roll number. A roll number has no caste or creed. So why do OBCs deserve reservation? In case of Dalits, one can understand the reservations. They have suffered from years of oppression, and are still suffering due to lack of resources. So the government decides to give them a helping hand to them. Krupal Kasyap

Posted by: Mr. ■Gumpulo Go!Vindam √ At: 4, May 2006 8:54:53 PM IST

Emandi Krishnaiah garu, Meeru Reservations lo kevalam BC la gurinchi matramey matladutunnaru. Edi correctenaa??? Assalu mana India lo Reservations enduku pettarandi..???? Venukabadda prajalndarini munduku teesukuravataniki. Avunanataraaa?? kadantaaraa?? Kaani Prati kulam lonu Dhanikulu mariyu pedavaallu unnaru. Adi OC, BC, SC, ST lalo. A politician choosinaa BC, SC, ST gurinchi matladataaru gani OC lo Leni vaalla gurinchi matladarenduku...? Antey vaallaku reservations akkaraledaaa?? Vallaki dikku evarandi...? Peru goppa uru Dibba annattu untundi OC lo peda valla bratuku.. Kaneesam eppudanna deenigurinchi alochinchaaraa...? Naa uddesam prakaram mana desam lo Reservations kevalam rendu vidhaaluga undali.. 1) Unnavaaru (Dhanikulu) 2) Lenivaaru (Peda vallu) Appudu matramey correct ga nyayam jarugutundi. Krishnaiah gaaru.. meeru okkasari OC kulalam lo oka Peda vadi postion lo nunchoni alochinchandi appudu meeku ardam avutundi.

Posted by: Mr. Sivasankar Reddy At: 4, May 2006 6:14:50 PM IST

Good valid points from all the comments from our friends on this Article. Who is Mr. Krishnaiah. He is making all this unnecessery comments to save his post. He doesnt have guts to ask reservations for all poor people not on cast basis. Without this post What is krishnaiah, in what areas he showed his merit. If this reservation policies continuous in IIMs and IITs no Fortune company will remain in India. So immediate action should taken by Mr. Krishnaiah is to show his merit in some useful work area.

Posted by: Mr. siva kameswara sridhar Kesiraju At: 4, May 2006 5:07:38 PM IST

This message voilated the guidelines of TeluguPeople.com. Hence it is deleted by the Site Administrator. TeluguPeople.com requests everyone to keep this site clean and good.

Posted by: Mrs. varma vasanth At: 4, May 2006 2:03:01 PM IST

Merit agrakulala sotthu kadu ani rasavu kada. Mari caste perita panchi ivvadama. Present Days meeru cheppe OBC class people engineering college ki bikes meeda,car lo vastunnaru aina reservation use cheuskuni free seat theesukuntunnaru.. At the same time below 3000 rank vachin kuda free seta dorakka ,Payment seat konaleka engineering apese upper caste valla gurinchi em cheppali.(-3) markulu vachina vadu BC ,SC,ST ani engineering seat lu enjoy chestaru Malli ippudu private companies lo kuda reservation kavala.. Aina if you have the guts and energy try to compete in an equal manner and develop. IIM ,IIT students entha kastapadutunnaro okkasari chudu.. Avanni emi lekuna only BC,SC,ST lo unnanduku kashtam lekunda IIT, IIM Seats enduku ivvali.Caste okate reason aithe , do not call India as a Secular country , Call it as a Backward Caste Country..

Posted by: Mr. Rajendra Rajendra Prasad K At: 4, May 2006 12:50:56 PM IST

a/c cars lo tirige ratan tata laku emi teluso naaku teliyadu kaani... reservations pratipadikana arhata anagadokkabadutunna.. Governemnet services ki, talent maatrame pramanikamai munduku doosukelutunna private ranganiki teda ... andariki telusu... agra kulalalo anta dabbunna valle leru.. pootagadavani endaro. chaduvu lo reservation ledu.. scholorship ledu... books etc sayam ledu... job kosam applicatiion cost, feese, travelling charges, malli reservation. inta cheste... vayo parimiti maro .. gudibanda..

Posted by: Mr. sampath kumar v At: 4, May 2006 12:44:21 PM IST

Do u think all upper caste people r rich?? Can't see poor people in upper castes?? R u blind?? Why don't u ask reservations for poor? Why do u want it on caste basis? U r using caste for ur selfish needs. Resign from that post first.

Posted by: Ms. bunny bunny At: 4, May 2006 10:26:48 AM IST

< < Previous Page: 2 of 3 Next > >